The membership of the Oyster Harbors Club voted with a 90% approval to replace their existing clubhouse with a new facility on the same site. The new clubhouse was designed in a traditional shingle style turn-of-the-century Cape Cod design with wrap around verandahs overlooking the starting and finishing holes of the Donald Ross designed Golf Course and to the waterway to the northwest.

Construction began in the Fall of 2005 and was completed in the Spring of 2006.